+10 votes
I am making a quick midweek chicken dinner tonight, but I want a lighter, balanced alternative to double cream... What is the best supermarket subsitute to make the sauce rich and tasty without splitting in the pan??? Greek yogurt turned out fine last time, but I need a reliable pantry staple for simple scratch cooking without fussy prep!!!
in Recipes and Cooking by

4 Answers

+5 votes
Best answer
Hello there. If you are looking for a reliable, lighter alternative to double cream that will not split over heat, I would strongly recommend keeping a tin of evaporated milk in your pantry.

Evaporated milk is regular cow's milk that has had roughly sixty percent of its water content removed. Because it undergoes high-temperature processing during canning, the milk proteins are already stabilized, making it far less prone to curdling or splitting when exposed to pan heat or mild acids. It provides a naturally smooth, creamy texture and coats the back of a spoon beautifully, all while having significantly less fat and fewer calories than double cream.

Another very forgiving option from the dairy aisle is reduced-fat creme fraiche or light cream cheese. Creme fraiche contains cultured acidity and proteins that tolerate heat much better than Greek yogurt. If you opt for cream cheese, simply whisk a tablespoon or two directly into your warm pan juices and stock until it melts into a silky sauce.

To put this into practice for a quick dinner: sear your chicken, set it aside, and deglaze the skillet with a splash of chicken stock or white wine to lift all the browned bits. Turn the heat down to low, pour in your evaporated milk, and let it gently simmer for a couple of minutes until velvety before returning the chicken to coat. I hope this helps you create a fantastic, balanced meal tonight.
by chef (156k points)
selected by chef
+7 votes
For a true homestyle comfort meal that keeps weeknight prep totally fuss-free, try a tin of light coconut milk or a quick white bean puree!!! Just do a quick pantry pull of canned cannellini beans, mash or blend them smoothly with a splash of warm chicken stock, and stir right into the skillet for an ultra-velvety dump-and-go base... It creates a rich, creamy consistency without splitting, keeps the calories light, and turns into pure cozy family comfort food every time!!!
by
+5 votes
Keeping weeknight dinners affordable and healthy is super important for me after a busy workday :)! My go-to pantry fix is canned light coconut milk or blending a spoonful of cornstarch into cold low-fat milk before pouring it into the skillet... Both options are super cheap, hold up amazingly well over heat without curdling, and give that velvety texture you want without all the heavy saturated fat!!! It makes a delicious sauce every single time...
by
+5 votes
If you want to keep your cost-per-portion low, a simple cornflour slurry with regular milk is the best bulk-buy pantry staple ever!!! Just mix one teaspoon of cornflour into cold milk untill dissolved, then stir it into the warm pan juices over low flame... It thickens up in two minutes, adds zero fuss, and is impossible to split even if you are in a rush... Total budget-friendly win for quick chicken dinners!!!
by