+15 votes
I bought a jar of pickled cucumbers on sale last week for a quick weeknight dinner and noticed today that the lid has popped up. Its completely swollen and bloated even though the seal was supposed to be fine when I bought it. I was planning to use them for dinner tonight so I really dont want to waste food if their still edible. Is it safe to eat them or is it better to throw the jar away?
in Products and Ingredients by

4 Answers

+5 votes
Best answer
Please do not eat those pickles. It is definitely safest to throw the jar away, and you should not attempt to taste or even smell them to test if they are fine.

When a sealed jar has a swollen or popped lid, it is a clear sign that gas has built up inside. Under normal conditions, properly canned goods maintain a vacuum seal. If gas accumulates to the point where the metal lid is bloated, it indicates active microbial activity. This happens when bacteria or wild yeasts either survived the processing stage or entered through an imperceptible breach in the seal. As these microorganisms feed on sugars and other components in the brine and cucumbers, they produce carbon dioxide and other gases.

While pickling uses acid to inhibit dangerous pathogens, a failed seal or improper acid balance can permit the growth of harmful bacteria, including Clostridium botulinum or other foodborne pathogens. Botulinum toxin and certain other dangerous bacterial toxins cannot be detected by smell, sight, or taste, which is why relying on a taste test is never worth the risk.

To dispose of the jar safely, place the entire unopened container into a plastic bag, seal it securely, and discard it in your regular outdoor trash so pets or wildlife cannot get into it. Since you just purchased it last week, you can also take a photo of the bloated lid and the receipt to request a refund or exchange from the store or manufacturer.
by leon-bernard (49.7k points)
selected by chef
+10 votes
1. Do not open the container yet... A swollen lid indicates positive pressure from internal gas accumulation!

2. Check the exterior for cracks or seal integrity failure...

3. In commercial pickles, this generally signals microbial activity! However, I am not certain whether the acidity makes it harmless yeast or severe spoilage... It is safer not to consume it until you check with the store for a refund!
by
+3 votes
Your dinner is currently planning an escape from that jar. I know the pressure means active bacteria inside, but whether it is a biohazard or just fizzy pickles is anyone's guess.
by
0 votes
I hate wasting ingredients for quick dinners! Just submerge the unopened jar in cold ice water for twenty minutes... The swelling is usually just temperature expansion from the store shelves!!!
by